Payroll & HR · Texas Payroll & HR Compliance Check

What would a Department of Labor audit cost your business?

Answer 15 questions in about 5 minutes. Get your Payroll & HR Risk Score, the penalties you may be exposed to, and the fixes that matter most. Free, no obligation.

A payroll compliance check is a quick review of how you classify workers, track hours, pay overtime, complete Form I-9s and handle tips, compared with the rules a Department of Labor or immigration audit applies. For Texas employers, it matters because federal law sets most of the rules, and each mistake is penalized per employee or per form — so small gaps add up to large back-wage and penalty bills.

Monica Shaw, SHRM-CP

Reviewed by Monica Shaw, SHRM-CP · Last updated November 2026

Free self-assessment

Score your payroll & HR risk

Worker classification, overtime, Form I-9, handbooks and — if you have tipped staff — tip pooling. Your results show on screen right away; no email required.

About 5 minutes · 15 questions · Free

Built by Monica Shaw, SHRM-CP, VP of Human Resources at Tribus Payroll & HR. Reviewed November 2026.

The 5 payroll and HR mistakes that trigger the most penalties for Texas employers

1. Treating employees as 1099 contractors

Associate providers, hygienists, paralegals and field hands paid on a 1099 while working your schedule with your equipment are often employees in the eyes of the DOL and IRS. Misclassification opens the door to back overtime and back payroll taxes.

2. Unpaid overtime from off-the-clock work

Setup before a shift, after-hours texts, travel between job sites and training all count as hours worked. Comp time and averaging hours across a two-week pay period are not allowed for private employers.

3. A regular rate that leaves out bonuses

Overtime is owed at 1.5 times the regular rate, which includes production pay, most bonuses, commissions and shift differentials. Leaving them out underpays every overtime hour.

4. Missing, late or unchecked Form I-9s

Every employee needs a completed I-9 within three business days of starting, kept for three years after hire or one year after termination. Each form with a problem can be fined separately.

5. Tip pools that include managers

Managers, supervisors and owners cannot share in employee tips. Getting this wrong can cost you the tip credit for every tipped employee, turning a small policy issue into large back-wage liability.

2026 federal penalty amounts at a glance

ViolationPenaltySource
Form I-9 paperwork violation$288 to $2,861 per formFederal Register (DHS)
Repeated or willful minimum wage or overtime violation (FLSA)Up to $2,515 per violation, plus back wages and equal liquidated damagesU.S. DOL WHD
Tip retention violation, including managers in a tip pool (FLSA)Up to $1,409 per violationU.S. DOL WHD
Example: January 2026 restaurant tip pool case$366,261 back wages + $47,282 civil penaltyDOL news release

Federal civil penalty amounts for 2026 remain at 2025 levels.

Who should take this check

  • Medical practices with clinical and front-desk staff
  • Dental practices with associates, hygienists and assistants
  • Law firms with paralegals and salaried staff
  • Restaurants and hospitality businesses with tipped employees
  • Oil & gas and field services companies with day-rate crews
  • Growing small businesses adding their first managers and locations

Frequently asked questions

What happens if I misclassify an employee as a 1099 contractor?

You can owe the worker back overtime and minimum wage, usually for two years (three if willful), plus an equal amount in liquidated damages. The IRS can also assess back payroll taxes and penalties. Repeated or willful wage violations add civil penalties of up to $2,515 each.

Does Texas have its own overtime law?

No. Texas does not have a separate state overtime law, so most Texas employers follow the federal Fair Labor Standards Act: time-and-a-half for hours over 40 in a workweek. Texas does have its own Payday Law, which governs when and how wages, final pay and deductions are handled.

How much are Form I-9 fines in 2026?

Paperwork violations on Form I-9 carry penalties of $288 to $2,861 per form. Federal civil penalty amounts for 2026 remain at 2025 levels. Because each form is fined separately, the total grows quickly with headcount.

Can managers share in a tip pool?

No. Federal law bars managers, supervisors and owners from keeping any part of employees' tips, including through a tip pool. Including them can invalidate your tip credit, and the DOL can assess up to $1,409 per tip violation.

Is an employee handbook required in Texas?

No law requires a handbook, but it is one of your best defenses. In Texas, PTO payout follows your written policy and most wage deductions need written authorization, so without written policies, wage claims are hard to defend.

How often should I audit my I-9 forms?

Review your I-9s at least once a year, and whenever you change onboarding staff or processes. A regular internal audit lets you correct errors properly before a government inspection, when corrections no longer help.

Sources

This check is an educational self-assessment, not legal advice. Results are based on your answers and on federal rules and Texas practice as of November 2026. Penalty figures are illustrative; actual liability depends on your facts. Talk with Tribus or your employment attorney before making changes.